Key Insights
Quick Answer
High roller comps are usually based on your expected value to the casino (theoretical loss), so the best comps are the ones you would have paid for anyway and that don’t push you into riskier play.
Best Way To Judge A Comp
Compare the real cash value of the perk to what you would have done without it, then make sure you’re not changing bet size or session length to “earn” it.
Biggest Advantage
When you evaluate comps like a rational trade, you stop chasing perks and keep your bankroll discipline intact.
Common Mistake
Assuming comps are “free,” then raising bets, playing longer, or switching games to qualify.
Pro Tip
Ask one clarifying question: “Is this comp upfront, or reviewed after play?” That prevents most misunderstandings.
What Comps Really Are
A comp is an investment. The casino spends something now, hoping to earn more from your future play. That’s why comps track your value, not your feelings.
Comps typically come from:
- Your expected value (theoretical loss)
- Your consistency (repeat sessions, stable average bet)
- Your history (frequency and loyalty)
- Your behaviour (easy to manage vs high-friction)
If you treat comps as rewards you “deserve,” you will usually make worse decisions. If you treat comps as an offer you evaluate, you stay in control.
The Truth About “Free”
Most comps have a real cost. Even when the casino’s cost is lower than the retail price, it’s still spending something.
What matters is whether the comp changes your behaviour. If it changes your behaviour, the comp becomes a lever that moves you into higher risk.
That’s the danger zone.
How Casinos Calculate High Roller Comps
Most VIP comp systems are built around theoretical loss, which is the casino’s estimate of what you are expected to lose based on house edge and your action.
A simplified view:
- Theoretical loss = house edge × total action
- Total action depends on average bet × pace × time played
This is why a steady $1,000 average bet for three hours often earns stronger support than a chaotic pattern with random spikes.
If you want the full breakdown of how VIP qualification is decided, read How Casinos Determine Who Qualifies as a VIP Player (Article #6).
Why Game Choice Changes Comp Speed
Higher house edge often means higher theoretical loss, which can “earn” comps faster. That’s why some players move into higher-edge games when they want perks.
But this is where many players lose the plot. They start paying a higher house edge to receive perks that are smaller than the extra cost.
Comps should be a side benefit, not a reason to choose a worse game for your bankroll.
Which Comps Are Actually Valuable
The best comps are the ones you would have paid for anyway and that genuinely improve your trip. They reduce real expenses without pushing you into higher volatility.
High-value comps often include:
- Room nights and suite upgrades you would otherwise pay for
- Dining credits at places you already planned to eat
- Late checkout and room location upgrades that reduce friction
- Priority access that saves hours during peak times
- Event tickets you value and would purchase
Lower-value comps often include:
- Random gifts you don’t care about
- Credits that expire quickly or require extra play
- Perks that sound luxurious but don’t change your experience
- “Free play” that encourages more risk
Soft Perks Can Beat Hard Perks
A suite sounds impressive. But a smoother trip can sometimes be worth more than a bigger room.
Soft perks that can be surprisingly valuable:
- Fast seating and smoother table access
- Reservation support and queue skipping
- Quiet, controlled space that protects focus
- Help solving small problems quickly
If you want to understand how these perks are negotiated, read How VIP Casino Hosts Negotiate Perks & Comps (Article #8).
The Comp Trap: When Perks Cost You More Than They’re Worth
Comps become expensive when they change your decisions. This is the main reason players lose money “chasing comps” even when they feel disciplined.
The comp trap shows up as:
- Extending sessions past your stop-loss
- Raising bets beyond your comfort zone
- Switching games to earn faster value
- Playing longer because “I’m close to something”
- Treating comps as a reason to ignore fatigue
The casino doesn’t need to trick you. The perk is enough of a nudge to make many players break structure on their own.
Why Chasing Comps Is A Psychological Leak
The moment you decide you “need” a comp, you start negotiating against your own limits. You turn a planned session into a mission.
High-stakes play is already pressure-heavy. Adding a perk target makes it worse because:
- You feel behind if the comp isn’t offered
- You rationalise risk to justify the goal
- You keep playing to “finish strong”
The fix is simple: decide your session plan first, then treat comps as a bonus if they fit.
A Simple Example With Numbers
Let’s compare two choices.
You want a suite upgrade worth $600 retail for one night. You consider pressing your bets to “make sure you qualify.”
Option A: Stay disciplined
- You keep your planned bet range
- You stop at your stop-loss
- You accept that the suite may not be guaranteed
Option B: Chase the perk
- You raise bets above your comfort zone
- You extend the session longer than planned
- You create bigger variance and higher risk of a blow-up
Use simple bullets when helpful.
- A $600 perk is never worth a $10,000 discipline break
- Chasing perks increases volatility, which increases emotional mistakes
- The best comps feel effortless because they fit your existing plan
If a perk requires you to break your structure, it’s not a perk. It’s a purchase made with bankroll risk.
Upfront Comps Vs Back-End Comps
This is where many misunderstandings happen. Some perks are confirmed upfront. Others are reviewed after your play is complete.
Upfront comps may include:
- Room nights and upgrades confirmed before arrival
- Dining reservations and set credits
- Event access if availability is locked in
Back-end comps may include:
- Additional room charges removed after review
- Extra dining credits after total action is calculated
- “We’ll take care of you” adjustments after the trip
The cleanest question you can ask:
- “Which parts are upfront, and which parts are reviewed after play?”
That one line protects your expectations and keeps the relationship calm.
Common Traps To Watch For
Trap one
Treating comps as proof of status, then taking rejection personally.
Trap two
Assuming retail value equals casino cost, then overvaluing what you’re getting.
Trap three
Pressing bets to “qualify,” then losing more than the perk is worth.
Trap four
Switching to higher house-edge games for faster comps.
Trap five
Letting vague host language become a guarantee in your mind.
Quick Checklist
Keep this short and scannable.
Step 1: Decide your session bankroll, stop-loss, and time limit first.
Step 2: Ask if the comp is upfront or reviewed after play.
Step 3: Value perks by real cash value, not by “VIP feeling.”
Step 4: Never raise bets or extend sessions just to earn a reward.
Step 5: Choose comps that reduce real costs you already planned to pay.
FAQs About High Roller Comps and Rewards
Are Comps Based On My Actual Win Or Loss?
Usually not. Many casinos base comps on theoretical loss, which depends on house edge and your total action, not your final result.
Do Higher Bets Always Mean Better Comps?
Not always. Consistency and time played matter a lot. A steady average bet over hours can outscore a few random spikes.
Is Free Play A Good Comp?
It can be, but it often increases volatility. Treat it like bankroll risk, not a gift, and don’t let it extend your session beyond your plan.
Why Did Someone Else Get Better Comps Than Me?
They may have played longer, returned more often, or generated higher theoretical value based on game choice and pace. Behaviour and history can matter too.
What’s The Best Comp To Ask For First?
Ask for something simple that improves your trip, like room upgrades, late checkout, or dining credit. These are easier to value and less likely to change your play.
Where To Go Next
Now that you understand the true value of high roller comps and rewards, the next step is learning high-stakes table etiquette so you don’t create friction in VIP spaces.
Next Article: High-Stakes Table Etiquette: What VIPs Must Know
Next Steps
If you want to understand how VIP value is calculated, read How Casinos Determine Who Qualifies as a VIP Player.
If you want to learn how hosts structure and approve perks, read How VIP Casino Hosts Negotiate Perks & Comps.
If your goal is to avoid VIP room mistakes, use Exclusive Pit Rules That Only Apply to High Rollers.
Gridzy Hockey is Shurzy’s daily NHL grid game where you pretend you’re just messing around and then suddenly you’re 15 minutes deep arguing with yourself about whether some 2009 fourth-liner qualifies as a 40-goal guy.
If you think you know puck, prove it. Go play Gridzy Hockey right now!
